I
recently had the incredible opportunity to attend a tour of the South Hebron
hills led by an organization called Breaking the Silence. The organization is
made up of veteran combatants who have served in Israeli Armed Forces during or since the
Second Intifada (which means in the last 12 years). The veterans involved are
individuals who want to inform Israelis and others about the reality of the Occupation as it is on the ground. They share testimonies of their experiences and give tours of Hebron and the South Hebron Hills
to explain the work of soldiers in these areas.
Our
guide served during the Second Intifada as part of a unit that performed night
arrests. This means when they had suspects to take to prison, they would go to
their homes at night and arrest them. Sometimes they would do as many as ten
arrests in a single night. He said that he and his fellow soldiers did their best to be “good
soldiers”. The soldiers found it hard to see how upset the Palestinian children were when they saw their father, mother or sibling being arrested. He said that he would try to look the kids in
the eye and show that he was a good man. Eventually, he started carrying
candies to give to the children so that they would not be as upset.
Our guide further explained that when they took over Palestinian homes to serve as
their home base for weeks or months at a time (a regular part of Israeli
Military policy in the West Bank), they would do their best to clean up the
house afterward when they gave it back to the Palestinian inhabitants. All in an attempt to be good soldiers.
However, our guide said that he eventually came to the conclusion that he could be the best possible soldier, but that did not change the fact that what he was being asked to do was immoral. The Occupation may be completely legal under Israeli law, but that does not make it moral. To hear a former combatant questioning the morality of the Israeli government policy toward Palestinians was extremely powerful.
However, our guide said that he eventually came to the conclusion that he could be the best possible soldier, but that did not change the fact that what he was being asked to do was immoral. The Occupation may be completely legal under Israeli law, but that does not make it moral. To hear a former combatant questioning the morality of the Israeli government policy toward Palestinians was extremely powerful.
One
important thing that this tour and the organization in general highlight is
that military occupation is obviously bad for the people being occupied, but it
also damages the occupiers. These former soldiers will never forget the things they
were asked to do, the things they experienced and what they witnessed during their terms of service.
I
am deeply impressed by Breaking the Silence and the former soldiers involved. I
can only imagine the courage and personal moral conviction it must take to
stand up against a system in which you actively participated. I am so honored
to have learned from our guide for the day and have renewed hope that change is
possible. When people within the system see it as unjust and are courageous enough
to work for change, it is a bit easier to believe that a further shore is
reachable from here.
